Chapter 1 › 1.2 Fundamental Theorem of Space Curves › 1.2.3 Fundamental Theorem
Subsection

1.2.3  Fundamental Theorem

We now state the main theorem of this section:

Theorem 1.23 (Fundamental Theorem of Space Curves)

Given any smooth positive function \(\alpha(s) : I \to (0, \infty)\), and a smooth real-valued function \(\beta(s) : I \to \R\), there exists an arc-length parametrized, non-degenerate curve \(\gamma(s) : I \to \R^3\) such that its curvature \(\kappa(s) \equiv \alpha(s)\) and its torsion \(\tau(s) \equiv \beta(s)\).

Moreover, if \(\bar{\gamma}(s) : I \to \R^3\) is another arc-length parametrized, non-degenerate curve whose curvature \(\bar{\kappa}(s) \equiv \alpha(s)\) and torsion \(\bar{\tau}(s) \equiv \beta(s)\), then there exists a \(3\times 3\) constant matrix \(A\) with \(A^T A = I\), and a constant vector \(p\), such that \(\bar{\gamma}(s) = A\gamma(s) + p\) for any \(s \in I\).

Checkpoint
The Fundamental Theorem of Space Curves (Theorem 1.23) states that \(\kappa(s)>0\) and \(\tau(s)\) determine the curve up to a rigid motion. Which transformation is a rigid motion here?
WhyThe theorem states \(\bar{\gamma}(s)=A\gamma(s)+p\) where \(A^TA=I\) (orthogonal) and \(p\in\R^3\). Such a map preserves distances and angles; it is a rotation or reflection composed with a translation, as also described in Remark 1.25.
Proof — revealed step by step

Step 1: Use the existence theorem of ODEs (Theorem 1.22) to show there exists a moving orthonormal frame \(\{\hat{e}_1(s), \hat{e}_2(s), \hat{e}_3(s)\}\) which satisfies an ODE system analogous to the Frenet-Serret System (1.6): \[(1.7)\qquad \begin{bmatrix}\hat{e}_1(s)\\\hat{e}_2(s)\\\hat{e}_3(s)\end{bmatrix}' = \begin{bmatrix}0&\alpha(s)&0\\-\alpha(s)&0&\beta(s)\\0&-\beta(s)&0\end{bmatrix}\begin{bmatrix}\hat{e}_1(s)\\\hat{e}_2(s)\\\hat{e}_3(s)\end{bmatrix}\] with initial conditions \(\hat{e}_1(0) = \hat{i}\), \(\hat{e}_2(0) = \hat{j}\), \(\hat{e}_3(0) = \hat{k}\). Since \(\alpha(s)\) and \(\beta(s)\) are smooth (in particular \(C^1\)), by Theorem 1.22 a solution exists on a maximal interval \(s \in (T_-, T_+)\).

We claim the frame \(\{\hat{e}_1(s), \hat{e}_2(s), \hat{e}_3(s)\}\) remains orthonormal as long as the solution exists. From (1.7) one derives (see Exercise 1.17): \[(1.8)\qquad \frac{d}{ds}\begin{bmatrix}\hat{e}_1\cdot\hat{e}_1\\ \hat{e}_2\cdot\hat{e}_2\\ \hat{e}_3\cdot\hat{e}_3\\ \hat{e}_1\cdot\hat{e}_2\\ \hat{e}_2\cdot\hat{e}_3\\ \hat{e}_3\cdot\hat{e}_1\end{bmatrix} = M(\alpha,\beta)\begin{bmatrix}\hat{e}_1\cdot\hat{e}_1\\ \hat{e}_2\cdot\hat{e}_2\\ \hat{e}_3\cdot\hat{e}_3\\ \hat{e}_1\cdot\hat{e}_2\\ \hat{e}_2\cdot\hat{e}_3\\ \hat{e}_3\cdot\hat{e}_1\end{bmatrix}\] for a certain matrix \(M(\alpha,\beta)\). The constant vector \((1,1,1,0,0,0)\) satisfies (1.8) with the given initial data. By the uniqueness theorem (Theorem 1.22), the dot products \((\hat{e}_i \cdot \hat{e}_j)\) remain equal to \((1,1,1,0,0,0)\) for all \(s \in (T_-, T_+)\), i.e. the frame stays orthonormal. Since the frame remains bounded, it extends to all \(s \in I\).

Step 2: Using \(\hat{e}_1(s)\) from Step 1, define: \[\gamma(s) = \int_0^s \hat{e}_1(s)\, ds.\] Then \(\mathbf{T}(s) := \gamma'(s) = \hat{e}_1(s)\) is unit, so \(\gamma(s)\) is arc-length parametrized. Computing the curvature: \(\gamma''(s) = \hat{e}_1'(s) = \alpha(s)\hat{e}_2(s)\), so \(\kappa(s) = |\gamma''(s)| = \alpha(s)\) and \(\mathbf{N}(s) = \hat{e}_2(s)\). By continuity of the orthonormal frame, \(\mathbf{B}(s) = \mathbf{T}(s)\times\mathbf{N}(s) = \hat{e}_3(s)\), and \(\mathbf{B}'(s) = \hat{e}_3'(s) = -\beta(s)\hat{e}_2(s) = -\beta(s)\mathbf{N}\), so \(\tau(s) = \beta(s)\).

Step 3 (Uniqueness): Suppose \(\bar{\gamma}(s)\) has the same curvature \(\alpha(s)\) and torsion \(\beta(s)\). Define the matrix \(A = [\bar{\mathbf{T}}(0)\; \bar{\mathbf{N}}(0)\; \bar{\mathbf{B}}(0)]\). By orthonormality, \(A^T A = I\). Both the Frenet-Serret Frame of \(A\gamma(s)+\bar{\gamma}(0)\) (namely \(\{A\mathbf{T}(s), A\mathbf{N}(s), A\mathbf{B}(s)\}\)) and of \(\bar{\gamma}(s)\) satisfy the same ODE (1.7), and they agree at \(s=0\). By Theorem 1.22, \(A\mathbf{T}(s)\equiv\bar{\mathbf{T}}(s)\). Setting \(f(s) := |\bar{\gamma}(s) - (A\gamma(s) - \bar{\gamma}(0))|^2\), we compute \(f'(s) = 2(\bar{\mathbf{T}}(s)-A\mathbf{T}(s))\cdot(\cdots) = 0\) and \(f(0)=0\), so \(f\equiv 0\) and \(\bar{\gamma}(s) \equiv A\gamma(s) + \bar{\gamma}(0)\).

Exercise 1.17

Verify (1.8).

Need help?

The existence part of Theorem 1.23 only shows a curve with prescribed curvature and torsion exists, but it is in general difficult to find such a curve explicitly. While the existence part does not have much practical use, the uniqueness part has some nice corollaries.

First recall that a helix is a curve of the form \(\gamma_{a,b}(t) = (a\cos t, a\sin t, bt)\) where \(a \neq 0\) and \(b\) can be any real number. Its arc-length parametrization is given by: \[\gamma_{a,b}(s) = \left(a\cos\frac{s}{\sqrt{a^2+b^2}},\; a\sin\frac{s}{\sqrt{a^2+b^2}},\; \frac{bs}{\sqrt{a^2+b^2}}\right).\] It can be computed that its curvature and torsion are both constants: \[\kappa_{a,b}(s) \equiv \frac{a}{a^2+b^2}, \qquad \tau_{a,b}(s) \equiv \frac{b}{a^2+b^2}.\] Conversely, given two constants \(\kappa_0 \gt 0\) and \(\tau_0 \in \R\), by taking \(a = \frac{\kappa_0}{\kappa_0^2+\tau_0^2}\) and \(b = \frac{\tau_0}{\kappa_0^2+\tau_0^2}\), the helix \(\gamma_{a,b}(s)\) with this pair of \(a\) and \(b\) has curvature \(\kappa_0\) and torsion \(\tau_0\). Hence, the uniqueness part of Theorem 1.23 asserts that:

Corollary 1.24

A non-degenerate curve \(\gamma(s)\) has constant curvature and torsion if and only if \(\gamma(s)\) is congruent to one of the helices \(\gamma_{a,b}(s)\).

Checkpoint
By Corollary 1.24, constant \(\kappa\) and \(\tau\) characterise helices. Which of the following is a special case of this result?
WhyA circle has constant positive curvature and zero torsion. By Corollary 1.24 it is congruent to a helix \(\gamma_{a,b}\) with \(b=0\), i.e., a circle of radius \(1/a\). Theorem 1.23 underpins this since both \(\kappa\) and \(\tau\) are constant.
Remark 1.25

Two space curves \(\gamma(s)\) and \(\tilde{\gamma}(s)\) are said to be congruent if there exists a \(3\times 3\) orthogonal matrix \(A\) and a constant vector \(p \in \R^3\) such that \(\tilde{\gamma}(s) = A\gamma(s) + p\). In simpler terms, one can obtain \(\tilde{\gamma}(s)\) by rotating and translating \(\gamma(s)\).

Checkpoint
Two curves are congruent according to Remark 1.25 if one is obtained from the other by an orthogonal map plus a translation. Which of the following pairs of curves are not necessarily congruent, even if they have the same curvature function \(\kappa(s)\)?
WhyThe Fundamental Theorem (Theorem 1.23) requires both \(\kappa\) and \(\tau\) to agree for congruence. Matching \(\kappa\) alone is insufficient: a right-handed and left-handed helix have the same \(\kappa\) but opposite \(\tau\), hence are not congruent. They are mirror images, not related by a pure rotation and translation as in Remark 1.25.