Chapter 4 › 4.1 Geodesic Curvature › 4.1.1 Geodesic equation
Subsection

4.1.1  Geodesic equation

The term geodesic essentially means the shortest path between a pair of points. For example, a straight line in a plane is a geodesic, and any great circle on a sphere is also a geodesic. The geodesic curvature of a regular curve on a surface measures how the curve deviates from being a geodesic. To begin, we should first understand how to find, or characterize, a geodesic. It turns out it is related to the covariant derivative.

Proposition 4.1

Suppose \(\gamma_0(t):[0,1]\to\Sigma^n\subset\mathbb{R}^{n+1}\) is a regular curve on a regular hypersurface \(\Sigma^n\), so that it is the shortest path on \(\Sigma^n\) between the points \(\gamma_0(0)\) and \(\gamma_0(1)\). Then, we have \[(4.1)\qquad \nabla_{\gamma_0'(t)}\!\left(\frac{\gamma_0'(t)}{|\gamma_0'(t)|}\right)=0\quad\forall\,t\in[0,1].\] Recall that \(\nabla\) denotes the covariant derivative, which is the projection of the directional derivative onto the tangent space.

Checkpoint
Proposition 4.1 states that a length-minimizing curve \(\gamma_0\) on \(\Sigma^n\) satisfies \(\nabla_{\gamma_0'(t)}\!\left(\frac{\gamma_0'(t)}{|\gamma_0'(t)|}\right)=0\). What does this equation say geometrically about the covariant acceleration of the unit tangent?
WhyThe covariant derivative \(\nabla\) projects the ambient derivative onto the tangent space of \(\Sigma\). Setting it to zero means there is no tangential component of the acceleration of the unit tangent — the curve does not \"turn\" within the surface. This is precisely what makes it a geodesic as in Definition 4.2.
Proof — revealed step by step

The technique used in the proof is commonly called Calculus of Variations — which frequently appears in physics. We consider a family of curves \(\{\gamma_u(t):[0,1]\to\Sigma^n\}_{u\in(-\varepsilon,\varepsilon)}\) so that \(\gamma_u(0)=p\in\Sigma\) and \(\gamma_u(1)=q\in\Sigma\) for any \(u\in(-\varepsilon,\varepsilon)\). When \(u=0\) we get the curve \(\gamma_0(t)\) given in the proposition. The parameter \(u\) gives the label of a curve in the family; varying \(u\) is like a deformation of the center curve \(\gamma_0(t)\).

For any fixed \(u\), the arc-length of \(\gamma_u\) is \(L(\gamma_u)=\int_0^1\left|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u(t)\right|dt\). We only assume \(\gamma_0\) is arc-length parametrized. For \(\gamma_0\) to be the shortest path we need \(\frac{d}{du}L(\gamma_u)\big|_{u=0}=0\). Differentiating under the integral and using the identity \(\frac{d}{du}\left|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u\right|=\frac{1}{|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u|}\left\langle\frac{d}{dt}\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u,\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u\right\rangle\) (where \(\frac{d}{dt}\) and \(\frac{d}{du}\) commute as \(u,t\) are independent), we get \[\frac{d}{du}L(\gamma_u)=\int_0^1\left\langle\frac{d}{dt}\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u(t),\frac{\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u(t)}{\left|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u(t)\right|}\right\rangle dt.\]

We use integration by parts to move the \(\frac{d}{dt}\) derivative onto the other factor: \[\frac{d}{du}L(\gamma_u)=\left\langle\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u,\frac{\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u}{\left|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u\right|}\right\rangle\bigg|_{t=1}-\left\langle\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u,\frac{\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u}{\left|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u\right|}\right\rangle\bigg|_{t=0}-\int_0^1\left\langle\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u,\frac{d}{dt}\frac{\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u}{\left|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u\right|}\right\rangle dt.\] Since \(\gamma_u(0)=p\) and \(\gamma_u(1)=q\) for all \(u\), the boundary terms \(\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u(0)=0\) and \(\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u(1)=0\), giving \[\frac{d}{du}L(\gamma_u)=-\int_0^1\left\langle\frac{d}{du}\gamma_u(t),D_{\gamma_u'(t)}\frac{\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u}{\left|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_u\right|}\right\rangle dt,\] where \(D\) denotes the directional derivative.

If \(\frac{d}{du}L(\gamma_u)\big|_{u=0}=0\) for any variation, then \(D_{\gamma_0'(t)}\frac{\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_0}{|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_0|}\big|_{u=0}\) must be orthogonal to every tangent vector of \(\Sigma\). Its projection onto the tangent space is zero, which is exactly \(\nabla_{\gamma_0'(t)}\frac{\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_0(t)}{|\frac{d}{dt}\gamma_0(t)|}=0\), completing the proof. \(\square\)

From high school calculus, we know that \(f'(a)=0\) does not always guarantee that \(f\) has a minimum at \(a\), as \((a,f(a))\) could be a maximum or a saddle point. At the same token, a curve \(\gamma_0\) satisfying (4.1) does not guarantee that it is the shortest path between \(\gamma_0(0)\) and \(\gamma_0(1)\). In high school calculus we call \((a,f(a))\) a critical point if \(f'(a)=0\); now we call a curve satisfying (4.1) to be:

Definition 4.2 (Geodesic)

A regular curve \(\gamma(t):[a,b]\to\Sigma^n\subset\mathbb{R}^{n+1}\) on a regular hypersurface \(\Sigma\) is said to be a geodesic on \(\Sigma\) if \[\nabla_{\gamma'(t)}\!\left(\frac{\gamma'(t)}{|\gamma'(t)|}\right)=0\quad\forall\,t\in[a,b].\] If further that \(\gamma\) is the shortest path on \(\Sigma\) between \(\gamma(a)\) and \(\gamma(b)\), then we call \(\gamma\) to be a minimizing geodesic.

Checkpoint
According to Definition 4.2, what is the difference between a geodesic and a minimizing geodesic?
WhyBy definition, every minimizing geodesic is a geodesic (it satisfies the covariant-acceleration equation), but the converse fails in general — a geodesic may fail to be globally shortest. For instance, a great circle arc longer than a semicircle is still a geodesic on the sphere but is not minimizing.
Example 4.3

Consider any great circle \(\gamma(s)\), parametrized by arc-length, on a round sphere. It is easy to see that \(\gamma''(s)\) is an inward-pointing normal vector of the sphere. Recall that \(\nabla_{\gamma'(s)}\gamma'(s)\) is the projection of \(D_{\gamma'(s)}\gamma'(s)\) onto the tangent plane. Note that \(D_{\gamma'(s)}\gamma'(s)\) is just the normal vector \(\gamma''(s)\), and so \(D_{\gamma'(s)}\gamma'(s)\) has no tangent component. This shows \[\nabla_{\gamma'(s)}\gamma'(s)=0.\] Hence \(\gamma(s)\) is a geodesic of the round sphere.

Checkpoint
In Example 4.3, great circles on the unit sphere are shown to be geodesics. The key observation is that \(\gamma''(s)\) for an arc-length parametrized great circle is a normal vector to the sphere. Why does this imply \(\nabla_{\gamma'(s)}\gamma'(s)=0\)?
WhyThe covariant derivative \(\nabla_{\gamma'}\gamma'\) is the orthogonal projection of \(D_{\gamma'}\gamma'=\gamma''(s)\) onto the tangent plane. Since \(\gamma''(s)\) points radially inward (normal to the sphere), it has no tangential component, so the projection is zero. This is the geometric heart of Example 4.3.
Example 4.4

Consider a rotational symmetric surface generated by the profile curve \(\gamma(t)=(x(t),0,z(t))\), where \(t\in(a,b)\), on the \(xz\)-plane such that \(x(t)>0\) for any \(t\in(a,b)\). The surface of revolution generated by \(\gamma\) is obtained by revolving \(\gamma\) about the \(z\)-axis, and it can be parametrized by \[F(t,\theta)=(x(t)\cos\theta,\,x(t)\sin\theta,\,z(t)),\qquad(t,\theta)\in(a,b)\times[0,2\pi].\] According to the calculations in p69, the first fundamental forms are given by: \[g_{tt}=x'(t)^2+z'(t)^2,\quad g_{t\theta}=0,\quad g_{\theta t}=0,\quad g_{\theta\theta}=x(t)^2.\] The components of the inverse matrix \([g]^{-1}\) are: \[g^{tt}=\frac{1}{x'(t)^2+z'(t)^2},\quad g^{t\theta}=0,\quad g^{\theta t}=0,\quad g^{\theta\theta}=\frac{1}{x(t)^2}.\] The Christoffel symbols are: \[\Gamma^t_{tt}=\frac{x'(t)x''(t)+z'(t)z''(t)}{x'(t)^2+z'(t)^2},\quad\Gamma^\theta_{tt}=0,\quad\Gamma^t_{t\theta}=0,\quad\Gamma^\theta_{\theta\theta}=0,\] \[\Gamma^\theta_{t\theta}=\frac{x'(t)}{x(t)},\quad\Gamma^t_{\theta\theta}=-\frac{x(t)x'(t)}{x'(t)^2+z'(t)^2}.\] For a curve of the form \(r(s)=F(t_0,\theta(s))\) with \(t_0\) fixed and \(\theta'(s)>0\), using properties (a)–(d) from p77 we compute \[\nabla_{r'(s)}\!\left(\frac{r'(s)}{|r'(s)|}\right)=-\frac{\theta'(s)x'(t_0)}{x'(t_0)^2+z'(t_0)^2}\,\frac{\partial F}{\partial t}.\] This shows \(r(s)\) is a geodesic if and only if \(x'(t_0)=0\). Geometrically, the \(\theta\)-curve generated by rotating \((x(t_0),0,z(t_0))\) about the \(z\)-axis is a geodesic precisely when \(x(t_0)\) achieves a local maximum or minimum.

Checkpoint
In Example 4.4, for a surface of revolution \(F(t,\theta)\), a parallel (circle of fixed \(t=t_0\)) is a geodesic if and only if which condition holds?
WhyThe covariant acceleration of the \(\theta\)-curve at fixed \(t_0\) is proportional to \(x'(t_0)\,(\partial F/\partial t)\). This vanishes exactly when \(x'(t_0)=0\), meaning the radius \(x(t)\) achieves a local extremum — geometrically the equator of a sphere, the waist of a torus, etc.
Exercise 4.1

Verify the Christoffel symbols of the above example.

Need help?
Exercise 4.2

Show that a regular curve of the form \(r(s)=F(t(s),\theta_0)\) where \(\theta_0\) is fixed must be a geodesic of the above surface of revolution.

Need help?
Exercise 4.3

Show that an arc-length parametrized geodesic \(r(s)=F(t(s),\theta(s))\) of a surface of revolution satisfies the following ODE system: \[\theta''(s)+\frac{2x'(t(s))}{x(t(s))}\theta'(s)t'(s)=0,\] \[t''(s)-\frac{x(t(s))x'(t(s))}{x'(t(s))^2+z'(t(s))^2}\theta'(s)^2+\frac{x'(t(s))x''(t(s))+z'(t(s))z''(t(s))}{x'(t(s))^2+z'(t(s))^2}t'(s)^2=0.\]

Need help?