Given an arc-length parametrized curve \(\gamma(s) : I \to \R^2\), we define the tangent frame \(\mathbf{T}(s)\) as in space curves, i.e.
\[\mathbf{T}(s) = \gamma'(s).\]
However, instead of defining the normal frame \(\mathbf{N}(s) = \frac{1}{\kappa(s)}\mathbf{T}'(s)\), we use the frame \(J\mathbf{T}(s)\) where \(J\) is the counter-clockwise rotation by \(\frac{\pi}{2}\), i.e.
\[J = \begin{bmatrix}0 & -1 \\ 1 & 0\end{bmatrix}.\]
One can easily check that \(\{\mathbf{T}(s), J\mathbf{T}(s)\}\) is an orthonormal frame of \(\R^2\) for any \(s \in I\). Let's call this the TN-Frame of the curve. We will work with the TN-Frame in place of the Frenet-Serret Frame for plane curves. The reasons for doing so are twofold. For one thing, the normal frame \(J\mathbf{T}(s)\) is well-defined for any \(s \in I\) even though \(\kappa(s)\) is zero for some \(s \in I\). Hence, one can relax the non-degeneracy assumption here. For another, we can introduce the signed curvature \(k(s)\):
Definition 1.26 (Signed Curvature)
Given an arc-length parametrized plane curve \(\gamma(s) : I \to \R^2\), the signed curvature \(k(s) : I \to \R\) is defined as:
\[k(s) := \mathbf{T}'(s) \cdot J\mathbf{T}(s).\]
Checkpoint
The signed curvature \(k(s)=\mathbf{T}'(s)\cdot J\mathbf{T}(s)\) in Definition 1.26 differs from the (unsigned) curvature \(\kappa(s)=|\gamma''(s)|\). What additional information does the sign of \(k\) encode?
WhyFrom Example 1.27, the unit circle traversed counter-clockwise has \(k=+1\) and clockwise has \(k=-1\), yet both have unsigned curvature \(\kappa=1\). The sign of \(k\) records the sense of turning, which the operator \(J\) (rotation by \(90^\circ\)) detects in the plane.
Note that \(\mathbf{T}(s)\) is unit, so by Lemma 1.7 we know \(\mathbf{T}(s)\) and \(\mathbf{T}'(s)\) are always orthogonal and hence it is either in or against the direction of \(J\mathbf{T}(s)\). Therefore, we have
\[|k(s)| = |\mathbf{T}'(s)||J\mathbf{T}(s)| = |\gamma''(s)| = \kappa(s).\]
The sign of \(k(s)\) is determined by whether \(\mathbf{T}'\) and \(J\mathbf{T}\) are along or against each other (see Figure 1.4).
Figure 1.4. Signed curvature.
Example 1.27
Let's compute the signed curvature of the unit circle
\[\gamma(s) = (\cos\varepsilon s,\, \sin\varepsilon s)\]
where \(\varepsilon = \pm 1\). The curve is counter-clockwise oriented when \(\varepsilon = 1\), and is clockwise oriented when \(\varepsilon = -1\). Clearly it is arc-length parametrized, and
\[\mathbf{T}(s) = \gamma'(s) = (-\varepsilon\sin\varepsilon s,\, \varepsilon\cos\varepsilon s)\]
\[J\mathbf{T}(s) = (-\varepsilon\cos\varepsilon s,\, -\varepsilon\sin\varepsilon s)\]
\[k(s) = \mathbf{T}'(s)\cdot J\mathbf{T}(s) = (-\varepsilon^2\cos\varepsilon s,\, -\varepsilon^2\sin\varepsilon s)\cdot(-\varepsilon\cos\varepsilon s,\, -\varepsilon\sin\varepsilon s) = \varepsilon^3 = \varepsilon.\]
Checkpoint
In Example 1.27, the unit circle parametrized as \(\gamma(s)=(\cos\varepsilon s,\sin\varepsilon s)\) with \(\varepsilon=\pm 1\) gives signed curvature \(k=\varepsilon\). Why does the signed curvature distinguish the two orientations while \(\kappa=|k|\) does not?
WhyThe unsigned curvature \(\kappa=|k|=1\) for both orientations. The signed curvature \(k=\mathbf{T}'\cdot J\mathbf{T}\) is positive when the curve bends left (counter-clockwise) and negative when it bends right (clockwise), as the calculation \(k=\varepsilon^3=\varepsilon\) in Example 1.27 confirms.
Exercise 1.18
Consider a plane curve \(\gamma(s)\) parametrized by arc-length. Let \(\theta(s)\) be the angle between the \(x\)-axis and the unit tangent vector \(\mathbf{T}(s)\). Show that:
\[\mathbf{T}'(s) = \theta'(s)\,J\mathbf{T}(s) \qquad \text{and} \qquad k(s) = \theta'(s).\]
Need help?
Scope — what to review
Review Definition 1.26 (signed curvature) and the rotation operator \(J\) (rotation by \(90^\circ\)). Note that if \(\mathbf{T}(s)=(\cos\theta(s),\sin\theta(s))\), then \(J\mathbf{T}=(-\sin\theta,\cos\theta)\).
Hint — how to proceed
Write \(\mathbf{T}(s)=(\cos\theta(s),\sin\theta(s))\) by definition of the angle \(\theta(s)\). Differentiate with respect to \(s\) using the chain rule to get \(\mathbf{T}'(s)=\theta'(s)(-\sin\theta,\cos\theta)=\theta'(s)J\mathbf{T}(s)\); then compare with \(\mathbf{T}'=k(s)J\mathbf{T}\) from Definition 1.26 to read off \(k(s)=\theta'(s)\).
Exercise 1.19
Consider a plane curve \(\gamma(s)\) parametrized by arc-length. Suppose \(|\gamma(s)|\) is maximum at \(s = s_0\). Show that:
\[|k(s_0)| \ge \frac{1}{|\gamma(s_0)|}.\]
Given a regular plane curve \(\gamma(t) : I \to \R^2\), not necessarily arc-length parametrized. Denote the components of the curve by \(\gamma(t) = (x_1(t), x_2(t))\).
Show that its signed curvature (as a function of \(t\)) is given by:
\[k(t) = \frac{\gamma''(t)\cdot J\gamma'(t)}{|\gamma'(t)|^3} = \frac{x_1'(t)x_2''(t) - x_2'(t)x_1''(t)}{(x_1'(t)^2 + x_2'(t)^2)^{3/2}}.\]
Hence, show that the graph of a smooth function \(y = f(x)\), when considered as a curve parametrized by \(x\), has signed curvature given by:
\[k(x) = \frac{f''(x)}{(1 + f'(x)^2)^{3/2}}.\]
Need help?
Scope — what to review
For the first part, use the fact that a maximum of \(|\gamma(s)|^2\) implies \(\frac{d}{ds}|\gamma(s)|^2=0\) and \(\frac{d^2}{ds^2}|\gamma(s)|^2\le 0\) at \(s=s_0\). For the formula in part (1), recall Definition 1.26 and the analogue of Proposition 1.8 for plane curves.
Hint — how to proceed
At the maximum \(s_0\): differentiate \(|\gamma|^2\) once to get \(\gamma\cdot\mathbf{T}=0\) (so \(\gamma\) is parallel to \(J\mathbf{T}\)), then differentiate again and use \(\mathbf{T}'=k J\mathbf{T}\) to obtain \(1+k(s_0)\,\gamma(s_0)\cdot J\mathbf{T}(s_0)\le 0\), leading to \(|k(s_0)|\ge 1/|\gamma(s_0)|\). For part (1) set \(\gamma=(x_1,x_2)\) and apply the cross-product curvature formula with \(J\gamma'=(- x_2',x_1')\).
The signed curvature characterizes regular plane curves, just as curvature and torsion characterize non-degenerate space curves.
Theorem 1.28 (Fundamental Theorem of Plane Curves)
Given any smooth real-valued function \(\alpha(s) : I \to \R\), there exists a regular plane curve \(\gamma(s) : I \to \R^2\) such that its signed curvature \(k(s) \equiv \alpha(s)\). Moreover, if \(\bar{\gamma}(s) : I \to \R^2\) is another regular plane curve such that its signed curvature \(\bar{k}(s) \equiv \alpha(s)\), then there exists a \(2\times 2\) orthogonal matrix \(A\) and a constant vector \(p \in \R^2\) such that \(\bar{\gamma}(s) \equiv A\gamma(s) + p\).
Checkpoint
The Fundamental Theorem of Plane Curves (Theorem 1.28) uses signed curvature \(k(s)\) rather than unsigned curvature \(\kappa(s)\). Why is the signed version essential?
WhyThe ODE for the tangent angle \(\theta'(s)=k(s)\) requires a signed quantity so the turning direction is encoded. Two curves with the same \(|k(s)|\) but opposite signs are mirror images; only by prescribing the signed \(k\) does Theorem 1.28 determine the curve up to a rigid motion (with \(A^TA=I\)).
Prove Theorem 1.28. Although the proof is similar to that of Theorem 1.23 for non-degenerate space curves, please do not use the latter to prove the former in this exercise. Here is a hint on how to begin the proof: Consider the initial-value problem
\[\hat{e}'(s) = \alpha(s)\, J\hat{e}(s), \qquad \hat{e}(0) = \hat{i}.\]
Need help?
Scope — what to review
Review Theorem 1.28 (Fundamental Theorem of Plane Curves) and Theorem 1.22 (Existence and Uniqueness of ODEs). The structure mirrors the proof of Theorem 1.23 but uses the \(2\times 2\) rotation-like ODE given in the hint.
Hint — how to proceed
Start with the IVP \(\hat{e}'(s)=\alpha(s)J\hat{e}(s)\), \(\hat{e}(0)=\hat{i}\). Use Theorem 1.22 to obtain a unique solution \(\hat{e}(s)\), then show \(\norm{\hat{e}(s)}=1\) for all \(s\) (differentiate \(\norm{\hat{e}}^2\)). Define \(\hat{e}_\perp=J\hat{e}\) and set \(\gamma(s)=\int_0^s\hat{e}(\sigma)\,d\sigma\); verify this curve has signed curvature \(\alpha(s)\) by Exercise 1.18.
Exercise 1.21
Using Theorem 1.28, show that a regular plane curve has constant signed curvature if and only if it is a straight line or a circle.
Need help?
Scope — what to review
Apply Theorem 1.28 (Fundamental Theorem of Plane Curves): a plane curve is determined up to rigid motion by its signed curvature function \(k(s)\). Recall that \(k=0\) characterizes lines and \(k=\text{const}\neq 0\) should characterize circles.
Hint — how to proceed
If \(k(s)=0\) for all \(s\), integrate \(\mathbf{T}'=kJ\mathbf{T}=\mathbf{0}\) to see \(\mathbf{T}\) is constant, giving a straight line. If \(k(s)=c\neq 0\) is constant, by Theorem 1.28 the curve is unique up to rigid motion; verify that the circle \(\gamma(s)=(\frac{1}{c}\sin(cs),-\frac{1}{c}\cos(cs))\) has signed curvature \(c\) using Exercise 1.18.
Exercise 1.22
Find an explicit plane curve \(\gamma(s)\) such that the signed curvature is given by \(k(s) = \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{s}}\).
Need help?
Scope — what to review
Use Theorem 1.28 (Fundamental Theorem of Plane Curves): given \(k(s)\), recover the unit tangent angle by \(\theta(s)=\int_0^s k(\sigma)\,d\sigma\) (see Exercise 1.18), then integrate \(\mathbf{T}\) to get \(\gamma\).
Hint — how to proceed
Compute \(\theta(s)=\int_0^s \frac{d\sigma}{\sqrt{\sigma}}=2\sqrt{s}\), so \(\mathbf{T}(s)=(\cos 2\sqrt{s},\,\sin 2\sqrt{s})\). Then \(\gamma(s)=\int_0^s(\cos 2\sqrt{\sigma},\sin 2\sqrt{\sigma})\,d\sigma\); use the substitution \(u=2\sqrt{\sigma}\) to evaluate the integrals in terms of Fresnel-like expressions.