Chapter 2 › 2.4 Maps and Functions from Surfaces › 2.4.2 Tangent Maps and Jacobian Matrices
Subsection

2.4.2  Tangent Maps and Jacobian Matrices

Let \(\Phi:M\to N\) be a smooth map between two regular surfaces. Instead of computing the matrix representation of the tangent map \(\Phi_*\) directly by taking partial derivatives (c.f. Example 2.26), one can also find it out by computing a Jacobian matrix.

Suppose \(\bF(u_1,u_2):U_M\to M\) and \(\bG(v_1,v_2):U_N\to N\) are local parametrizations of \(M\) and \(N\). The composition \(\bG^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF\) can be regarded as a map between the \(u_1u_2\)-plane to the \(v_1v_2\)-plane. As such, one can write \(\bG^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF(u_1,u_2)=(v_1(u_1,u_2),v_2(u_1,u_2))\). By considering \(\Phi\circ\bF(u_1,u_2)=\bG(v_1(u_1,u_2),v_2(u_1,u_2))\), one can differentiate both sides with respect to \(u_i\):

\[\pd{}{u_i}(\Phi\circ\bF)=\pd{}{u_i}\bG(v_1(u_1,u_2),v_2(u_1,u_2))=\sum_{k=1}^{2}\pdG{v_k}\pd{v_k}{u_i}.\tag{2.1}\]

Here we used the chain rule. Note that \(\big\{\pdG{v_k}\big\}\) is a basis for \(T_{\Phi(p)}N\). Using (2.1), one can see \[\Phi_*\!\left(\pdF{u_1}\right):=\pd{\Phi}{u_1}=\pd{}{u_1}(\Phi\circ\bF)=\pd{v_1}{u_1}\pdG{v_1}+\pd{v_2}{u_1}\pdG{v_2},\] \[\Phi_*\!\left(\pdF{u_2}\right):=\pd{\Phi}{u_2}=\pd{}{u_2}(\Phi\circ\bF)=\pd{v_1}{u_2}\pdG{v_1}+\pd{v_2}{u_2}\pdG{v_2}.\]

Hence the matrix representation of \((\Phi_*)_p\) with respect to the bases \(\big\{\pdF{u_i}(p)\big\}\) and \(\big\{\pdG{v_i}(\Phi(p))\big\}\) is the Jacobian matrix \[\Jac{v_1,v_2}{u_1,u_2}\Big|_{\bF^{-1}(p)}=\begin{bmatrix}\pd{v_1}{u_1}&\pd{v_1}{u_2}\\[2pt]\pd{v_2}{u_1}&\pd{v_2}{u_2}\end{bmatrix}_{\bF^{-1}(p)}.\]

Checkpoint
With respect to the chart bases \(\big\{\pdF{u_i}\big\}\) on \(M\) and \(\big\{\pdG{v_i}\big\}\) on \(N\), the matrix of the tangent map \((\Phi_*)_p\) is:
WhyWriting \(\bG^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF(u_1,u_2)=(v_1,v_2)\) and applying the chain rule (2.1) shows that \((\Phi_*)_p\) sends \(\pdF{u_i}\) to \(\sum_k\pd{v_k}{u_i}\pdG{v_k}\). So in these bases its matrix is precisely the Jacobian \(\partial(v_1,v_2)/\partial(u_1,u_2)\). (It is the identity only in special cases, like the rotation in Example 2.27.)
Example 2.27

Let \(\Phi:S^2\to S^2\) be the rotation map as in Example 2.26. Consider again the local parametrization \(\bF(\theta,\varphi)=(\sin\varphi\cos\theta,\sin\varphi\sin\theta,\cos\varphi)\). By standard trigonometry, one can find out that \(\Phi(\bF(\theta,\varphi))=\bF(\theta+\alpha,\varphi)\). Equivalently, the map \(\bF^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF\) (in a suitable domain) is the map \((\theta,\varphi)\mapsto(\theta+\alpha,\varphi)\).

As \(\alpha\) is a constant, the Jacobian matrix of \(\bF^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF\) is the identity matrix, and so the matrix \([(\Phi_*)_p]\) with respect to the bases \(\big\{\pd{\bF}{\theta},\pd{\bF}{\varphi}\big\}_p\) and \(\big\{\pd{\bF}{\theta},\pd{\bF}{\varphi}\big\}_{\Phi(p)}\) is the identity matrix (which was also obtained by somewhat tedious computations in Example 2.26). \(\square\)

Checkpoint
Example 2.27 finds that \(\bF^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF:(\theta,\varphi)\mapsto(\theta+\alpha,\varphi)\), so its Jacobian is the identity. Therefore the matrix \([(\Phi_*)_p]\) in the basis \(\{\pd{\bF}{\theta},\pd{\bF}{\varphi}\}\) is:
WhySince adding the constant \(\alpha\) to \(\theta\) has Jacobian \(\begin{psmallmatrix}1&0\\0&1\end{psmallmatrix}\), the tangent map is represented by the identity in this chart basis — even though \(\Phi\) genuinely moves points, the coordinate velocities are unchanged.
Exercise 2.28

Do Exercise 2.27 by considering Jacobian matrices.

Need help?
Checkpoint
Definitions 2.14 and 2.18 demand the \(C^k\) property for every chart. Why do Remarks 2.15 and 2.19 say checking one chart (one pair of charts) is enough?
WhyBy Proposition 2.12 the transition maps between charts are smooth. Switching to another chart just pre-/post-composes \(f\circ\bF\) (or \(\bG^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF\)) with smooth transition maps, and compositions of \(C^k\) maps between Euclidean spaces stay \(C^k\). So the property in one chart transfers to all charts.