Let \(\Phi:M\to N\) be a smooth map between two regular surfaces. Instead of computing the matrix representation of the tangent map \(\Phi_*\) directly by taking partial derivatives (c.f. Example 2.26), one can also find it out by computing a Jacobian matrix.
Suppose \(\bF(u_1,u_2):U_M\to M\) and \(\bG(v_1,v_2):U_N\to N\) are local parametrizations of \(M\) and \(N\). The composition \(\bG^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF\) can be regarded as a map between the \(u_1u_2\)-plane to the \(v_1v_2\)-plane. As such, one can write \(\bG^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF(u_1,u_2)=(v_1(u_1,u_2),v_2(u_1,u_2))\). By considering \(\Phi\circ\bF(u_1,u_2)=\bG(v_1(u_1,u_2),v_2(u_1,u_2))\), one can differentiate both sides with respect to \(u_i\):
\[\pd{}{u_i}(\Phi\circ\bF)=\pd{}{u_i}\bG(v_1(u_1,u_2),v_2(u_1,u_2))=\sum_{k=1}^{2}\pdG{v_k}\pd{v_k}{u_i}.\tag{2.1}\]
Here we used the chain rule. Note that \(\big\{\pdG{v_k}\big\}\) is a basis for \(T_{\Phi(p)}N\). Using (2.1), one can see \[\Phi_*\!\left(\pdF{u_1}\right):=\pd{\Phi}{u_1}=\pd{}{u_1}(\Phi\circ\bF)=\pd{v_1}{u_1}\pdG{v_1}+\pd{v_2}{u_1}\pdG{v_2},\] \[\Phi_*\!\left(\pdF{u_2}\right):=\pd{\Phi}{u_2}=\pd{}{u_2}(\Phi\circ\bF)=\pd{v_1}{u_2}\pdG{v_1}+\pd{v_2}{u_2}\pdG{v_2}.\]
Hence the matrix representation of \((\Phi_*)_p\) with respect to the bases \(\big\{\pdF{u_i}(p)\big\}\) and \(\big\{\pdG{v_i}(\Phi(p))\big\}\) is the Jacobian matrix \[\Jac{v_1,v_2}{u_1,u_2}\Big|_{\bF^{-1}(p)}=\begin{bmatrix}\pd{v_1}{u_1}&\pd{v_1}{u_2}\\[2pt]\pd{v_2}{u_1}&\pd{v_2}{u_2}\end{bmatrix}_{\bF^{-1}(p)}.\]
Let \(\Phi:S^2\to S^2\) be the rotation map as in Example 2.26. Consider again the local parametrization \(\bF(\theta,\varphi)=(\sin\varphi\cos\theta,\sin\varphi\sin\theta,\cos\varphi)\). By standard trigonometry, one can find out that \(\Phi(\bF(\theta,\varphi))=\bF(\theta+\alpha,\varphi)\). Equivalently, the map \(\bF^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF\) (in a suitable domain) is the map \((\theta,\varphi)\mapsto(\theta+\alpha,\varphi)\).
As \(\alpha\) is a constant, the Jacobian matrix of \(\bF^{-1}\circ\Phi\circ\bF\) is the identity matrix, and so the matrix \([(\Phi_*)_p]\) with respect to the bases \(\big\{\pd{\bF}{\theta},\pd{\bF}{\varphi}\big\}_p\) and \(\big\{\pd{\bF}{\theta},\pd{\bF}{\varphi}\big\}_{\Phi(p)}\) is the identity matrix (which was also obtained by somewhat tedious computations in Example 2.26). \(\square\)
Do Exercise 2.27 by considering Jacobian matrices.